The New Jim Crow by Michelle Alexander
Who
is more blameworthy: the young black kid who hustles on the street corner,
selling weed to help his momma pay the rent? Or the college kid who deals drugs
out of his dorm room so that he’ll have cash to finance his spring break? (Alexander
216)
In
an attempt to better understand our guests, community, and the world, the staff
at LPCS has developed a monthly book club. This past month the staff attempted
to grasp the significance of “The New Jim Crow: Mass Incarceration in the Age
of Colorblindness” by Michelle Alexander.
First
question on the table was: who managed to finish the book? This New York Times
Bestseller is over 200 heavy pages challenging the racism that exists from America’s
neighborhood policing up through to the 14th Amendment. While many
people considered the election of Barack Obama an end to racism, Alexander
proposes that we have not yet entered an era of colorblindness, but rather
redistributed racism back into the justice system.
There
were many interesting points of conversation that occurred after reading the
book. Murray pointed out how, when it comes to drug related crimes, it is interesting
that there is no actual victim. No one is actually calling the police to report
a crime because both parties involved (the dealer and the purchaser) is willing
participants. After the emergence of the War of Drugs, police learned new
tactics of finding criminals and then prosecuting them without a crime actually
being reported.
Once
arrested, few drug related crimes actually go to trial. Some people will remain
in jail for a significant amount of time. Others will plead guilty because they
will have charges stacked on top of themselves and do not have the resources
for a strong lawyer. Odds are rarely in the favor of the person arrested, so a
plea bargain is often the only way out.
It
is important to always consider how these concepts relate to the guests at
LPCS. Alexander pointed out how difficult it is for a person to get a home once
they have been arrested for anything, even if it occurred decades ago. A person
that felt obligated to plead guilty to a charge from over 15 years ago is often
going to find him or herself without a home or job because many places will not
take anyone with a record. “Throughout the United States, public housing
agencies have adopted exclusionary policies that deny eligibility to applicants
even with the most minor criminal backgrounds” (Alexander 145). Job
applications will also weed out all of the people that have a background. Even
if a person chooses to decline to answer, that often sends a red flag up to the
employer or landlord.
So,
what can be done to rehabilitate someone who has done their time but is out of
options now that they are a free person again? We were not able to come up with
any realistic solutions, only frustrations. Can you think of any ways around
this system?
Respond
with your thoughts and suggestions below -
By: Meghan Freebeck
4 comments:
Great post. What a wonderful idea to have a book club. I love the many ways that LPCS develops positive and respectful interaction.
-- Gil
A very timely discussion, since Mayor Emanuel just approved a new policy on possession of small amounts of marijuana...instead of criminal charges, a fine will be issued for possession of less than 15g. The policy change had wide support because nearly 90% of cases were dismissed, using up police resources and detracting focus from more serious crimes, and because the law disproportionately affects people of color, even though drug use among all races is comparable. A small step in the right direction!
http://www.ward49.com/site/epage/135096_322.htm
For more information on the new marijuana policy in Chicago
Thanks for the link, estesgirl! It was great timing to read this book while Chicago was making these changes.
An interested stat was given in the novel, it said that the majority of drug charges were against people of color, and that the majority of people hospitalized for drug related activity were Caucasian.
You make a great point, hopefully the change will allow our police to focus on other crimes, such as the increase in homicides in Chicago.
If anyone would like to follow in our Book Club, we will be reading "Beautiful Boy" and "Tweak" at the same time to compare a parent's perspective and a child's perspective on drug abuse.
Post a Comment